Research (Grade XII 2007-08)
Conclusion:
Christopher Paolini’s Inheritance Book trilogy is fundamentally plagiarized from J.R.R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings trilogy.
Evidence:
1. The most influential of the Rangers of Gordon in the LOTR trilogy is baptized Aragorn and performs probably the most prominent role next to Frodo.
Meanwhile, in the IB trilogy, the central character, on whose experience the books are written, is christened Eragon, bearing a stark resemblance to Aragorn of the LOTR trilogy.
2. In the LOTR trilogy, another of the Rangers of Gordon, Boromir, plays the closest relation to Aragorn in The Fellowship of The Ring. Unfortunately, Boromir is killed in the very first book of the trilogy while trying to protect two half-lings (children) of Hobbiton.
In the IB trilogy, the closest friend and teacher Eragon has at the beginning of the trilogy is named Brom, a strikingly similar name to Boromir. Coincidentally or not, Brom, too, is killed in the first book of the trilogy, defending Eragon.
3. In the LOTR trilogy, Aragorn is in love with an elf-princess, whose name is Arwen.
Eragon, meanwhile, in the IB trilogy, falls in love with an elf-princess too, whose name, Arya, happens to bear a striking similarity to that of the LOTR trilogy.
4. In both the trilogies, the lead elf-princesses happen to be half-orphans.
5. In the LOTR trilogy, the lead character, Frodo Baggins, flees from his home in order to prevent getting caught by the Wraith, malicious soldiers under the command of the lead evil character, Sauron.
The lead character of the IB trilogy, Eragon, also flees his home in order to escape from the Ra’zac, evil soldiers working for the evil king, Galbatorix.
6. In the LOTR trilogy, Frodo’s only living relation is his uncle, who lives with Frodo.
Eragon, in the IB trilogy, also has only one direct living relation, an uncle, who also happens to live with Eragon.
7. Frodo, from the LOTR trilogy, and Eragon from the IB trilogy, both happen to be simple villagers until they are suddenly burdened with the task of saving the world.
8. J.R.R. Tolkien, a household name and an excellent writer, used a good strategy by not revealing Sauron, the lead evil character, till the third and final book.
Christopher Paolini, an apparent teenage plagiarist, also seems to have used the same strategy by keeping the entrance of Galbatorix, the lead evil role, till the last book of the trilogy.
9. The LOTR trilogy witnesses Frodo embark on a long journey, most of it through deserted lands.
Eragon makes a strikingly similar journey through the Hadarac desert à la IB trilogy.
10. Bilbo, who happens to give Frodo his magical sword in the LOTR trilogy, happens to be a good friend of the elves and later stay with them.
In the IB trilogy, Brom, who gives Eragon his sword, is also a good ally and agent for the elves.